Media

July 28, 2005 - The Beacon Mutual Insurance Company (Beacon) has emerged victorious in U.S. District Court in its suit against OneBeacon Insurance Group (OneBeacon) over the use of the OneBeacon name and logo which Beacon claimed violated service mark infringement and trade dilution under Rhode Island state law. Last week’s ruling by U.S. District Court Judge William E. Smith granted injunctive relief to Beacon, prohibiting OneBeacon from using the OneBeacon name and lighthouse logo in Rhode Island.

Beacon, the largest writer of worker’s compensation in the state of Rhode Island, has used the name “The Beacon Mutual Insurance Company” (along with a lighthouse logo) since 1992. In 2001, OneBeacon (formerly known as CGU Insurance) adopted its current name and also began to use a lighthouse logo. Almost immediately, Beacon noticed confusion by those individuals (including RI employers, employees, vendors, attorneys and court personnel) that use the worker’s compensation system and filed suit. OneBeacon responded with a motion for summary judgment which was granted. As counsel for Beacon, Steven E. Snow of Partridge Snow & Hahn LLP, filed an appeal which resulted in the First Circuit Court reversing the earlier ruling, agreeing with the plaintiff that the previous scope for defining the confusion had been too narrow. The First Circuit defined a new standard of what constitutes actionable confusion by finding: “Confusion is relevant when it exists in the minds of persons in a position to influence the purchasing decision, or persons whose confusion presents a significant risk to the sales, goodwill, or reputation of the trademark owner.”

As a result of the First Circuit’s decision, the case returned to the U.S. District Court and a week-long bench trial was held. Judge Smith’s decision in favor of Beacon was released on July 15, 2005.